10.1.10

Proximity






Hak Nam. Kowloon Walled City. City of Darkness.
Demolished in 1933.
35,000 people living in 200m x 100m of solid building


making my house
central : the temple
the idea of " self construction" :
illegal growth/autonomous district,
establishing territories
question of control
forgetting "capsular" civilization: the pack animal
rules of the game
ownership/governance of space
what does it mean to have to share?


31.12.09

Author's Statement

SHARE SYSTEMS. A Prototype for Making Family


Canada is rich with an ethnic, cultural and linguistic mix from more than 200 countries of origin. We are largely foreigners in this land, choosing to make it our own. Many have come in search of new opportunities, freedom and safety; each bringing a wealth of knowledge, memories, customs and histories. According to Charles Taylor, the building of a democratic Canadian society “requires a politics that leaves room for us to deliberate publicly about those aspects of our identities that we share, or potentially share with other citizens. A society that recognizes individual identity will be a deliberative , democratic society because individual identity is partly constituted by collective dialogues”. We are part of a young nation that enjoys both the particularities and the peculiarities, of each new culture. It is in the confrontation and clashing of cultural elements that new things can begin. The unfamiliar and uncomfortable moments --what we call “awkward”-- are often hastily avoided despite the fact that they could represent a new type of possibility, a different type of growth. What better place to begin understanding the potential of these times than in the fundamental unit of the house, the home, the family.


I am now Canadian, having spent one third of my life in India, one third in Oman and one third in Canada. I am not alone in what I bring to this country -- this is the norm. I have had many homes in Canada: one that I shared with my immigrant family of grandmother, parents and sister, another where I lived with seven students, once strangers now friends, with backgrounds from Trinidad, the Philippines, small town Ontario, Israel, Shanghai, and El-Salvador, and lastly my student apartment where I lived alone. The constant shift between living with family, friends and on my own has changed me; I make my own family.


This thesis examines, predictively as well as descriptively, emerging living systems that strengthen the growing demographic of culturally diverse “chosen” families. Dwelling units have been more commonly understood as housing provided for 1, 2, 4, or 100 people: the studio apartment for the bachelor, a semi-detached home for the couple, a single family suburban home for the young family or an apartment block for seniors. With a few variations, this has been the general theme. In the light of the emerging reality of the “chosen” family, there appears to be room for a prototype that encourages 7-12 people to live together in one unit. These are distressed times, both financially and socially, where seniors are lonely, young families struggle without household help and middle-aged couples still pay large mortgages in their “empty nest” homes. We cope. Seniors move into annexes of their children’s homes, two young families share responsibilities, and middle-aged couples wish they could sell their properties to move into a joint home with friends. This is happening all around us, and much could be done to provide the infrastructure to both accommodate and encourage the shift.The codependency of “chosen” families is crucial in strengthening individuality and community, thus maintaining self identity while reducing alienation.


This is an experiment.

Tentative Outline

SHARE SYSTEMS. A prototype for making family

Title
Author’s Statement
Abstract
Executive Summary
Outlining terms and the Phenomenological Method
The realities of the multicultural experience: Who we are and what we bring
Table of Contents / List of Illustrations

PART ONE: Think

Making Contemporary Families
“Yours and Mine” Cross-cultures: Japan, India, Europe
Learning from the joint family
Belonging and Alienation
Awkward Living Systems
Balancing Privacy and Exposure, Secret and Spectacle
Obsessing about Interiority
The Un-Private House
Surveillance and Responsibility
Shared Spaces: Benefits and Problems

PART TWO: Learn

Ontario
Single family home conversions and statistics: Financial and Social Implications
Typologies between the house and the apartment: Scale and Program
Emerging Living Systems
Architectural Elements and Forms
Section
Building for the : Individual+Stranger/ Individual+Family/ Family+Stranger
Interface : Identifying Thresholds, Barriers, Markers
Material, Distance, Orientation, Levels, Movement, Duration of stay

PART THREE: Experiment

Cambridge Case Study
The Midsize Town Condition
Students and Seniors: Housing Prototype
The 7-12 person unit
Design Proposal

Conclusions

Appendices
Bibliography

20.12.09

M1 Reviews

PART ONE: Awkward Living Systems

Tracing the new dialect of “yours and mine” in Canada’s multicultural society, the following report is a
culmination of literary ideas and design explorations that examine the shifting lines between private and
public space at the different scales of contemporary everyday life. Each is a further investigation into architecture’s delineation of those spaces that frame communal as well as individual identity in every culture and especially at the intersection of cultures.

The “awkward” need not be uncomfortable, but rather can be embraced, for it represents the interface of that which is alien to one culture but familiar to another. Perhaps it embraces a new series of moments in architecture that heighten the varying perceptions of privacy and exposure , that eventually creates a new medium to realize a sense of identity. By playing with the notion of isolation and belonging; seclusion and integration, each exercise will reconstruct a stimulating experience of space, place and meaning where there was none.
( Author's Statement)

(Panel 1)
INDIVIDUAL + FAMILY. Our families no longer consist of mother, father and son, instead we have grandmother, mother, and daughter. Three individuals that still cling to the nostalgia of the familial unit. We live together because it is convenient, affordable and comforting. Learning from the Mobius House, the form of this compact dwelling is manipulated to accommodate three distinct individuals, each with their own schedules, their own requirements and demands. The form of the compact house follows the intertwining trajectory relating to a 24-hour lifestyle of work, play and sleep with only a few moments to meet and greet each other. The section allows for a palpable awarness between private and public by the warping of party walls that create interlocking shared space. Circulation space in the house are flattened into a series of screens that become a negotiating medium between “yours and mine”. The importance of maintaining a visual connection through the rooms become the primary tool that allows individuals to retain their privacy and strengthen community.
The traditional living room is now the study - where talking has been replaced by typing and storey telling is referenced by gmail. The study and the kitchen are the places to gather. The single family house becomes a amalgamated form of two apartments. This isn’t a novel idea as housing typologies in other cultures usually include annexes for the joint family or separate living quarters for servants. Mother and daughter share the bottom floor while grandmother lives on the third floor. By establishing a sense of independence and privacy required by each individual , the house becomes a flexible system of units that maintain their own entrances but are joined at the core. Allowing for the choice of being alone, or being together.

(Panel 2)

FAMILY + STRANGER. The house is a perch; a temporary resting place for a family to grow. The design of this dwelling is particularly interested in inventing new hierarchies; other types of relationships rather than purely narrative spaces that have a beginning and an end. Attempting to design ‘situations’ rather than designating one room per person and making common rooms an after thought, the house imagines spaces to weave into each other, become private around a corner or public when open to the courtyard. Movement and Gesture play a crucial role in the form of the architecture; both filter sporadically rather than be designated as “circulation” space. Public and private become relational and contingent rather than absolute. Both can occur anywhere. Privacy is generated by withdrawing from company and th public is confronted by interaction. The home becomes a retreat and the family finds privacy in spaces like the library and not necessarily the bedroom.
The residents of the house (whom are treated in this experiment as one unit) interact with the ‘stranger’ who visits the site. Traditionally the ground floor of homes are the most public zones , and at each raised level the rooms are more exclusive and private. This house experiments with allowing the public to move fluidly through every level of occupation. Thus it adopts a double spiral form, one for private living the other for public platforms. The structure of the house becomes the tool which mediates between what is exposed and what is hidden. Walls render rooms independent or shared with crafted openings. Instantly they become both connected and independent of each other.
(Panel 3)
INDIVDUAL + STRANGER. This is the most abstract version of what the house is meant to be. It deals with raw confrontation and heightens extremely awkward moments between the occupants of the site. The site becomes one large piece of structure which makes the levels of privacy of the units within the house ambiguous. The lack of orientation allows each occupant or visitor of the site to deal directly with the wall beside them at each moment; by understanding the position they are standing in, who is watching them, who is beside them, then only can the individual understand the concept of the house.
In our egocentric society based on the discourse of “I”, we are still not afraid to show and tell. The project places programs such as bathrooms in very publicly viewed locations, however a physical distance remains which gives the illusion of privacy.

1.12.09

HOUSE 2

Author, Site, 2009

"House 2" is interested in inventing new hierarchies; other types of relationships rather than purely narrative spaces that have a beginning and an end. I am learning to design 'situations' rather than designating one room per person and making common rooms an after thought.



Author, Plans, 2009
  1. Highly differentiated and intricately woven spaces
  2. Movement filters rather than designating "circulation" space
  3. Public+ Private are relational and contingent rather than absolute. Both can occur anywhere. Privacy is generated by withdrawing from company and Public is confronted by interaction.
  4. Privacy. Becomes a "retreat", in this case, the library and not necessarily the bedroom.
  5. Public. Family, Friend, and Stranger are addressed and movement is choreographed on every level.
  6. Walls are rendered independent rooms together with crafted openings. Indecently they become both connected and independent of each other.

Author, Remembering Scenes, 2009

30.11.09

Third Order of Simulacra




"The point of view of modern architecture is never fixed, as in baroque architecture, or as in the model of vision of the camera obscura, but always in motion, as in film or in the city. Crowds, shoppers in a department store, railroad travelers, and the inhabitants of Le Corbusier’s houses have in common with movie viewers that they cannot fix (arrest) the image. Like the movie viewer that Benjamin describes (“no sooner has his eye grasped a scene than it is already changed”), they inhabit a space that is neither inside nor outside, public nor private (in the traditional understanding of these terms). It is a space that is not made of walls but of images. Images as walls..."
- Beatrice Colomina, Privacy and Publicity


"...Obscenity begins when there is no more spectacle, no more stage, no more theatre, no more illusions, when everything becomes immediately transparent, visible exposed in the raw and inexorable light of information and communication. We no longer partake of the drama of alienation, but are in the ecstasy of communication." - - Jean Baudrillard, The Ecstacy of Communication


25.11.09

The overlap

FRIEDLANDER, Lee, “Newark, New Jersey, 1962”,
Photographs, New York, Haywire, 1978

FRIEDLANDER, Lee, “Hillcrest, New York, 1970”,
Like a One-Eyed Cat, Photographs by Lee Friedlander 1956-1987,
New York, Abrams, 1989.


FRIEDLANDER, Lee, “Texas, 1965”,
Like a One-Eyed Cat, Photographs by Lee Friedlander 1956-1987,
New York, Abrams, 1989.

FRIEDLANDER, Lee, “New York City, 1963”,
Photographs, New York, Haywire, 1978


Lee Friedlander’s unique vision underscores the two-dimensionality of the picture plane and the potential for photographs to contain varying levels of reflection, opacity, and transparency. Friedlander’s images of shop windows evoke a certain ambiguity, an oscillation between reflected and actual reality, that invite inspection of the space and the meaning of the image. Similar responses are encouraged by Friedlander’s street photographs, in which shadows of figures (usually Friedlander himself) and other subjects overlap in the photographic image. The projected outline of Friedlander’s body as within the picture frame implies the notion that the photographer can be both behind the camera and in front of it. Interpreted further, Friedlander’s shadow can be taken to represent the imposition of the photographer upon his world and his subject.

Reference: Museum of Contemporary Photography , Chicago

Seeking new horizons

We yearn for uncertainty in our environment; the uncanny balance between yours and mine, alien and home. While protected and intimate enclosures at the end of a familiar path offer security, opportunity rises from ambiguous territories that allow for exploration. We seek out suspense in space.

"Though the house is an area of security and peace for man, he would pine away if he locked himself in his house to escape the dangers of the world outside; the house would soon become a prison. He must go out into the world to transact his business and to fulfill his role in life. Both security and danger belong to man, and consequently both areas of lived-space, as life develops in the tension between outer and inner space. " (O.F. Bollnow)

There is a growing obsession in contemporary culture with the awkward systems prevalent in both our homes and the city. At each scale there is a personal investment made by the inhabitant to understand and move through space. The impulse of the traveler is to pursue; either for sheer enjoyment or personal pleasure, but always for satisfaction. As early as ancient Greece, Aristotle contended that strange things with complicated aesthetics brought pleasure to the viewer. The process of trying to understand how and why things are the way they are has followed us ever since. Edmund Husserl and M. Merleau-Ponty indicate that our perception of the world is not a series of unrelated shots but rather hinges from one phase to the next, forming a continuous; we constantly imagine what lies behind closed doors.
The following is a study on design guidelines that will be investigated as a template to understanding how to craft the identity of spaces that offer both security and opportunity.

The Basic Structure of a suspenseful situation consists of seven components: a barrier; realms created by the barrier; a target hidden in the unknown realm; human interest associated with the target; hints disclosing the target; various expectations aroused by the hints; and the feeling of suspense proper generated during this process.

Diagram Credit : Miao, Pu


Prescribing Four Patterns of Uncertainty to specific forms of suspenseful places.

Diagram Credit : Miao, Pu


Reduplication
Spiritual Barrier and Hint
Guiding Element
Movement
Unusual View
Incompleteness
Association of Human Being
Infinity
Light from Unseen Sources

Relevance in
Intimate Space. The House
Sacred Space. The Temple
Public Space. The Piazza

Circumstantial Factors in Spatial Suspense
Cultural Factors
Viewer's Previous Knowledge: frequency of users in the space


Reference: Pu Miao, Suspense of Space: Theory and Design.

17.11.09

Breaking Territorial Structure

"Everyday personal experience of small scale settlement is usually limited to places in which we or our relatives, close friends and colleagues live, work or shop. When we exit into the public realm, the world seems to comprise giant infrastructures and ubiquitous institutions. While traveling, we do not easily venture beyond familiar networks. Visiting distance cities and countries, we seldom penetrate into small scale domestic worlds where we do not know anyone. We may not even notice their vast extent as we fly over them. We experience the modern world as increasingly public and large scale, while in the actual occupation of the earth's surface, the small scale and the local is growing at a tremendous rate." N.J. Habraken, Structure of the Ordinary

What if we could reverse ordinary patterns.

Rethinking the apartment

a narrow sunroom ("engawa"), which constitutes an intermediate space or buffer zone between interior and exterior.


The Gifu Kitagata project proposes a shared urban community of closely knit apartments that create an urban allegory of the village. The circulation routes, storage space and laundry areas are used as the physical and communal connections. These are zones that are given the least attention in contemporary residential design.
Sejima allows the daily chores of laundry and basic house maintenance , usually completed by the women of the household, to become more prominent.

"These free zones of undefined ownership become "baits" for the inhabitants to gain extra space, more light and better ventilation. By enhancing the idea of sharing resources, this colonization of spaces tends to break the isolation of social housing and creates various types and sizes of communal space for the inhabitants to meet one another, hang out, team up and exchange conversation: a modem envision of the traditional neighbourhood.

Such communal space ultimately leads to the genuine public space of the housing scheme, blurring the boundary between the private garden and the public space. As a result, the design as a whole attempt to rethink how housing units and shared spaces function spatially, and on a macro perspective, how the identity of a locale is defined. "